In the first excerpt, which is from the 1884 Report of Tenement House Commission in New York City, it describes living conditions in tenement houses. The text highlights issues related to privy vaults and water supply in these buildings. It explains that privy vaults are considered a danger to public health due to their proximity to windows and the potential for leakage, odor, and the spread of diseases. The report recommends the abolition of privy vaults and the installation of water closets for better sanitation. It also emphasizes the importance of adequate water supply on each inhabited floor.
The second excerpt is from The Hull House Maps and Papers, which provides insights into how immigrants settled in Chicago. It highlights the presence of different nationalities in specific areas of the city. The Italians are mentioned as being primarily concentrated in certain tenements, while the Russian and Polish Jews form another distinct group. The Bohemians are described as occupying better streets, and the Irish are mentioned as being numerically significant on Forquer Street. The excerpt also mentions the presence of French, colored people, Chinese, Arabians, Greeks, Syrians, Turks, and other immigrant groups, which contribute to the cosmopolitan nature of the neighborhood.
In the third excerpt, the discussion shifts to living arrangements and wages. It explains that the census data used for the wage-map represents households rather than individuals. Families, including extended relatives and boarders, often shared the same tenements and cooking facilities. This arrangement led to crowded living conditions, such as sixty men sleeping in one basement room. The text mentions that boarding and lodging houses were prevalent in the area as well.
The fourth excerpt is a letter from John Aton, a banker from Los Angeles, written in 1901. Aton addresses the Chinese Exclusion Act, specifically the restrictions on Chinese immigrants visiting their home country and returning to the United States. He argues that the limitations on who can visit their families in China cause hardship and encourage fraudulent practices. Aton suggests that anyone who has complied with the Registration Law and holds a Certificate of Residence should be allowed to visit their native land and return, reducing the potential for impersonation and promoting the welfare of these individuals.
To compare and contrast the experiences of immigrants east and west of the Mississippi River, we can use the highlighted text and information from each excerpt:
Similarities:
1. Living conditions in tenements: Both the immigrants in the east (New York City) and west (Chicago) faced challenges related to crowded tenement housing, inadequate sanitation (privy vaults), and the need for better water supply.
2. Ethnic clustering: In both regions, immigrants tended to form ethnic enclaves or colonies within certain neighborhoods. Italians, Jews (Russian, Polish), Bohemians, and Irish settled in distinct areas of Chicago, while New York City had various immigrant groups concentrated in specific tenements.
Differences:
1. Geographic location: The immigrants settled east of the Mississippi River, primarily in New York City, while those discussed in the other excerpts settled in the Midwest or on the West Coast (specifically Chicago and Los Angeles).
2. Specific ethnic groups: Each region had a unique mix of ethnic groups. In the east, there were Italian and Jewish populations, while the west had a larger presence of Scandinavians (not mentioned in the excerpts), and Chinese immigrants were mentioned specifically in the Los Angeles letter.
3. Living arrangements: The third excerpt highlights the crowded living conditions in which families and boarders shared tenements, whereas the other excerpts do not provide detailed information about such arrangements in the western context.
By analyzing these differences and similarities, we can understand how the lives of immigrants varied in terms of location, ethnic composition, and living conditions. The excerpts shed light on the challenges, experiences, and cultural diversity of immigrants settling in different regions of the United States during the late 19th and early 20th centuries.
4
Get Answer
1
